Why In-Studio Feedback is Essential for Your Music?

Why In-Studio Feedback is Essential for Your Music?

Date: 6-June-2023

At a music recording studio, music artists, producers, and engineers collaborate to create something unique. It offers a collaborative environment where ideas can flourish and become a reality. During music production and engineering, feedback determines whether a project is on track. However, it can be challenging to strike the right balance between providing helpful feedback and not being too harsh or critical when it comes to constructive criticism. In this blog, we'll look at how music artists, producers, and engineers can provide constructive criticism and the value of feedback in the music studio.

Ways music artists and engineers/producers can provide constructive criticism

1.      Start with a positive comment

Let us start with not being too harsh! While providing feedback, it's crucial to begin it with something positive. This creates an atmosphere of support and makes the recipient of the feedback feel more open to helpful criticism. For instance, during music production and engineering, if you are an engineer critiquing a music artist's composition, you might start by saying, "I really love the melody you've created here. It's very memorable and catchy. However, you can…”. You can then pinpoint the required changes to be made.

2.      Be specific and actionable

Always remember to provide specific and practical feedback. Providing vague feedback can be annoying and worthless. Constructive criticism in music production and engineering consists of giving specific recommendations for how to improve areas that could be improved. Thus, rather than saying, "This part doesn't sound good," you should try saying, "I think the snare drum could benefit from some more reverb to create a more expansive sound."

3.      Focus on the music, not the person

Next, when you are critiquing, remember, your criticism must be directed at the piece of work, not the artist. Avoid uttering something like "You’re not good at this" or "This is terrible." Instead, concentrate on the precise areas of the work that can be made better. Saying "Your vocals are terrible," for instance, should be replaced by, "I think your vocals could benefit from some more practice and training."

4.      Offer suggestions for improvement

Constructive criticism involves not just critiquing but also providing some suggestions. While you are involved in music production and engineering, try to offer specific solutions or suggestions for how the work could be improved, as opposed to just pointing out the issues. For instance, if as a music artist, you are critiquing an engineer's mix, you must give some advice, such as you can say lower the volume of some instruments or increase the amount of reverb to give the music more space.

5.      Use "I" statements

It's critical to own your opinions and feelings when offering feedback in music production and engineering. Use "I" statements to express your viewpoint in a non-confrontational and non-judgmental manner. For instance, instead of directly saying, "You're not correct here," try saying, "I feel if you can make a more dynamic arrangement, this portion can have a better sound."

6.      Balance criticism with praise

It's crucial to strike a balance between constructive criticism and recognition of what's working well. Emphasizing the music's positive aspects boosts self-esteem and motivates the other person to keep pushing their creative boundaries. As a music artist, when giving feedback to the engineer, you may say, "I really love the melody you've created here. It's very memorable and catchy. However, to build a stronger sense of rhythm, I believe the drums could be a little more prominent in the mix.”

Value of feedback in the recording studio

Now, having talked about how you can provide criticism, let’s look at some of its benefits.

  • It helps to refine the creative vision

Feedback is useful in music production and engineering for honing a project's creative vision. It enables music artists, producers, and engineers to collaborate and share ideas to determine the best course of action. This makes it more likely that the final result will be something of which everyone can be proud.

  • It aids in problem identification and resolution

Feedback is essential for identifying and solving issues that might arise during the creative process. It enables the team to collaborate in order to find a solution and proceed, regardless of whether there is a technical issue with the instrumentation or a problem with the song's structure.

  • It creates the best version of the work

Most importantly, feedback enhances the quality of the final version of the musical creation. Together, during music production and engineering, artists, producers, and engineers can produce work that exceeds their expectations by offering constructive criticism and ideas for enhancement. This increases the chance of the project's success and makes it more fulfilling for everyone involved.

  •  It fosters collaboration and trust

A culture of collaboration and trust is developed in the music production and engineering process when feedback is given and received in a respectful and constructive manner. This inspires everyone to express their opinions and cooperate to realize their creative ambitions. This fosters a productive workplace that encourages innovation and creativity.

  • It helps to develop skills and knowledge

Finally, feedback is crucial because it fosters the growth of everyone involved in music production and engineering in terms of knowledge and skills. Artists and engineers/producers can learn from their errors and create new methods and approaches to their craft by receiving feedback. They become better at what they do as a result, and the industry as a whole also benefits from this.


Thus, during music production and engineering, feedback plays a crucial role. It refines creative vision, creates the best version of the music, identifies and resolves issues, develops skills and knowledge, and enhances cooperation and trust. Everyone involved in the recording process can achieve their creative goals and produce something truly unique by providing and receiving feedback in a constructive and respectful manner.

MIX Recording Studio in Los Angeles is one of the best places for music production and engineering. At this cutting-edge studio, we offer several services related to music production, such as rental studio, recording sessions, mixing and mastering services and professional photography and videography. Besides, it has a friendly environment where music artists, sound engineers/producers freely give their opinions to produce the best music.


Website's supported by B-ID